In a recent decision the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal has dismissed a complaint of unlawful disability discrimination and ordered costs against the applicant, finding that the employer was unaware of the disability, had no unreasonable requirements, and could not have unlawfully discriminated against the employee.

The Facts

The employer was a not-for-profit organisation that operated the Heartbeat Market, a welfare enterprise.

The employee was interviewed on 14 July 2022 and commenced employment as a casual Driver/Storeman.

He signed a medical declaration disclosing that he had no pre-existing conditions that would affect his ability to perform his role.

He was taken through an induction process and given an induction manual which required him to report hazards and any injuries immediately. After his induction he completed his first shift. He did not report any hazards.

Thereafter he regularly contacted his direct manager reporting that he was unable to work due to tiredness and that he suffered from sleep apnoea. He kept working after his first shift but did not report any issues other than being tired.

On 4 October 2022 he resigned from his position.  He did not return to work.

On 5 October 2022 he contacted the employer to complain he had injured his shoulder at work. The employer invited him to notify its workers compensation insurer.

On 4 November 2022 he sent a completed application for workers’ compensation to the employer which was submitted to the insurer.  The application stated he had not reported the injury during the employment.

On 9 May 2023 he attended the Heartbeat Market and confronted a manager about his workers’ compensation application, which was still in the hands of the insurer.  He became aggressive and was asked to leave the staff area.  After asking for clarification he said, “That’s all I need.”

After the application for workers’ compensation was rejected, he applied to the NSW Civil and Discrimination Tribunal alleging dismissal and unlawful discrimination on the basis of a disability.

The Decision

The Tribunal Senior Member dismissed the application finding that:

  1. The employer was unaware of the disability.
  2. The employer had no unreasonable requirements or employment conditions that indirectly discriminated against the employee.
  3. In those circumstances unlawful discrimination could not be established.

Costs Ordered

The Senior Member also ordered that the employee should pay the employer’s legal costs of the proceeding, observing that:

  1. The claim had no reasonable basis in fact or law and the proceedings were frivolous, vexatious, and misconceived.
  2. During the proceedings the employer sent a letter to the employee stating it would apply for costs if he did not engage in resolution discussions, and that the employee’s failure to engage in dispute resolution and accept offers made for resolving the dispute had caused disadvantage to the employer.
  3. The employee had not acted in accordance with a guiding principle in the legislation which is to “facilitate the just, quick, and cheap resolution of the real issues in the proceedings.”
  4. These amounted to special circumstances to justify making a costs order.

Implications

For employees the case underlines the importance of ensuring that proceedings are brought with a proper basis and are conducted appropriately.

For employers the case illustrates the importance of:

  • Appropriate pre-employment procedures for the disclosure of pre-existing conditions that affect a job applicant’s ability to perform the role.
  • Workplace policy requiring the disclosure of injuries and incidents at work.
  • Managing complaints and claims by a proper process.

At WorkLegal our experienced team can answer your questions and put you on the right track. A range of fixed-price Initial Consultations will suit most people’s needs in quickly learning what their options are.